Birkenstock Arizona Vs Mayari: Which One Reigns Supreme?

By Macie Langosh May 29, 2025

When it comes to sandals, Birkenstock has been the go-to choice for decades. The brand's iconic Arizona and Mayari styles are two of the most popular options out there. But what's the real difference between them? If you're debating between Birkenstock Arizona vs Mayari, you're not alone. Let's dive deep into this footwear showdown and figure out which one deserves a spot in your closet.

Picture this: you're scrolling through online stores or browsing at your local shoe shop, and there they are – two pairs of Birkenstock sandals staring back at you. One's called Arizona, and the other's Mayari. They look similar, but something tells you they're not exactly the same. That's because they're not! While both sandals are crafted with the same legendary comfort that Birkenstock is known for, they have distinct features that set them apart. So, how do you choose?

Let's break it down for you. Whether you're a seasoned Birkenstock fan or just dipping your toes into the world of orthopedic footwear, this guide will help you understand the nuances of the Arizona vs Mayari debate. By the end, you'll know exactly which pair aligns with your style and comfort needs.

Understanding the Birkenstock Brand

Before we dive into the specifics of the Arizona vs Mayari comparison, it's important to understand why Birkenstock is such a big deal in the world of footwear. Founded in Germany back in 1774, Birkenstock has been crafting high-quality, comfortable shoes for over 250 years. The brand is famous for its innovative footbed design, which supports your feet like no other sandal can. It's no wonder they've become a global phenomenon!

What makes Birkenstock so special? For starters, their footbed is designed to mimic the natural shape of your foot. It features an arch support, a deep heel cup, and a toe grip that keeps your feet secure and comfortable all day long. Whether you're walking, standing, or just lounging around, Birkenstock sandals provide unparalleled support and comfort. And let's not forget their commitment to sustainability – many of their products are made from eco-friendly materials.

Now that we've established why Birkenstock is a footwear powerhouse, let's focus on the two stars of today's showdown: Arizona and Mayari.

Introducing the Birkenstock Arizona

The Classic Two-Strap Design

The Birkenstock Arizona is one of the brand's most iconic styles, and for good reason. Featuring a classic two-strap design, this sandal is all about simplicity and functionality. The straps are adjustable, allowing you to customize the fit to your liking. Whether you have wide or narrow feet, the Arizona can accommodate you with ease.

But it's not just about the straps. The Arizona's footbed is what truly sets it apart. Made from high-quality cork and latex, it molds to the shape of your foot over time, providing personalized support and cushioning. This adaptability is why so many people swear by the Arizona for all-day comfort.

Another great feature of the Arizona is its versatility. While it's often associated with casual wear, the clean lines and minimalist design make it a great option for more formal settings as well. Pair it with jeans, shorts, or even a dress, and you've got a winning look.

Meet the Birkenstock Mayari

Adding a Third Strap to the Mix

The Birkenstock Mayari is essentially an upgraded version of the Arizona. While it retains the same footbed and overall design, it adds a third strap that wraps around the toes. This extra strap not only enhances the aesthetic appeal but also provides additional support and security.

For those who spend a lot of time on their feet, the Mayari's added strap can make a big difference. It helps keep your foot in place, reducing the risk of slippage and ensuring a more stable stride. This makes it an excellent choice for activities like hiking, walking, or even standing for long periods.

Style-wise, the Mayari strikes a balance between casual and chic. The third strap adds a touch of elegance to the design, making it a great option for those who want to elevate their footwear game. Plus, it comes in a variety of colors and materials, so you can find the perfect pair to match your personal style.

Key Differences Between Arizona and Mayari

Design Features

At first glance, the Arizona and Mayari might look similar, but there are some key differences to consider. The most obvious distinction is the number of straps. The Arizona features two adjustable straps, while the Mayari adds a third strap for extra support. This additional strap gives the Mayari a slightly more polished look, which some people prefer.

Another difference lies in the level of foot coverage. The Mayari's third strap provides more coverage around the toes, which can be a plus in colder climates or for those who want a bit more protection. On the other hand, the Arizona's simpler design might appeal to those who prefer a more open, airy feel.

Comfort and Support

Both the Arizona and Mayari offer excellent comfort and support thanks to Birkenstock's signature footbed. However, the Mayari's extra strap can provide a bit more stability, which is great for long walks or standing for extended periods. If you have particularly wide or narrow feet, the Arizona's two straps might offer a bit more flexibility in terms of adjustment.

It's worth noting that the footbed molds to your foot over time, so both sandals will become more comfortable with use. However, the initial break-in period might be a bit challenging for some people, especially if you're not used to wearing Birkenstocks.

Style and Versatility

When it comes to style, the Arizona and Mayari both have their own unique appeal. The Arizona's clean, minimalist design makes it a great option for casual settings, while the Mayari's extra strap adds a touch of sophistication. If you're looking for a sandal that can transition from day to night, the Mayari might be the better choice.

In terms of versatility, both sandals can be dressed up or down depending on your outfit. The Arizona pairs well with casual wear like jeans and t-shirts, while the Mayari can elevate a more polished look with skirts or dresses. Ultimately, the choice comes down to your personal style preferences.

Price Comparison

Are You Getting What You Pay For?

When it comes to price, the Birkenstock Arizona and Mayari are fairly similar. Both sandals are considered mid-range in terms of cost, with prices typically ranging from $90 to $120 depending on the material and color. While the Mayari might be slightly more expensive due to the additional strap, the difference is usually negligible.

It's important to remember that Birkenstocks are an investment. While they might cost more upfront than other sandals, their durability and comfort make them worth the price. Many people find that they can wear their Birkenstocks for years with proper care, making them a cost-effective choice in the long run.

Who Should Choose Arizona?

The Minimalist's Dream

If you're someone who appreciates simplicity and functionality, the Birkenstock Arizona might be the perfect choice for you. Its two-strap design offers a classic, timeless look that pairs well with a variety of outfits. Plus, the adjustable straps allow for a customized fit that can accommodate a wide range of foot shapes and sizes.

The Arizona is also a great option for those who value versatility. Whether you're heading to the beach, running errands, or meeting friends for coffee, this sandal can keep up with your busy lifestyle. Its lightweight design and breathable materials make it ideal for warm weather, ensuring your feet stay cool and comfortable all day long.

Who Should Opt for Mayari?

Extra Support and Style

For those who need a bit more support and stability, the Birkenstock Mayari is the way to go. The third strap provides additional security, making it a great choice for long walks, hikes, or any activity that requires extended periods of standing. If you have flat feet or other foot issues, the Mayari's extra support can make a big difference in your comfort level.

Style-wise, the Mayari offers a bit more flair than the Arizona. The third strap adds a touch of elegance to the design, making it a great option for those who want to elevate their footwear game. Whether you're dressing up or dressing down, the Mayari can add a polished touch to your outfit.

Customer Reviews and Ratings

What the Fans Are Saying

When it comes to customer reviews, both the Arizona and Mayari receive high marks for their comfort and durability. Many users appreciate the customizable fit and the way the footbed molds to their feet over time. Some even claim that their Birkenstocks have become their go-to footwear for everyday use.

That said, there are a few common complaints. Some users find the initial break-in period uncomfortable, while others wish the sandals came in more colors or materials. However, these minor drawbacks are often outweighed by the overall benefits of owning a pair of Birkenstocks.

Final Verdict: Arizona vs Mayari

So, which one should you choose? Ultimately, the decision comes down to your personal preferences and needs. If you're looking for a simple, versatile sandal that can keep up with your busy lifestyle, the Birkenstock Arizona is an excellent choice. Its minimalist design and adjustable straps make it a great option for casual wear.

On the other hand, if you need a bit more support and stability, the Birkenstock Mayari might be the better option. Its third strap provides additional security, making it ideal for long walks or extended periods of standing. Plus, its polished design adds a touch of elegance to any outfit.

No matter which pair you choose, you can't go wrong with Birkenstock. Both the Arizona and Mayari offer unparalleled comfort and support, making them a worthwhile investment for anyone who values quality footwear.

Call to Action

Now that you know the ins and outs of the Birkenstock Arizona vs Mayari debate, it's time to make your move. Head over to your favorite shoe store or browse online to find the perfect pair for your needs. And don't forget to share your thoughts with us – we'd love to hear about your experience with these iconic sandals!

So, which one will it be? Let us know in the comments below, and don't forget to check out our other articles for more footwear tips and tricks. Happy shopping!